(DOWNLOAD) "Brown and Others, Plaintiffs in Error, Against the State of Maryland, Defendant in Error" by United States Supreme Court # Book PDF Kindle ePub Free
eBook details
- Title: Brown and Others, Plaintiffs in Error, Against the State of Maryland, Defendant in Error
- Author : United States Supreme Court
- Release Date : January 12, 1827
- Genre: Law,Books,Professional & Technical,
- Pages : * pages
- Size : 98 KB
Description
Feb. 28th. Mr. Meredith, for the plaintiffs in error, contended, that the law in question was an unconstitutional exercise of the taxing power of Maryland. He did not deny the existence of such a power. As a necessary incident to sovereignty, it belonged to the several States before the adoption of the constitution, and it still belongs to them, subject, however, to the restrictions imposed upon its exercise by the paramount authority of that instrument. With regard to these restrictions, he did not mean to contend, that the general grant contained in the eighth section of the first article of the constitution, vested in the national government any thing more than a concurrent power of taxation. He admitted the rule of construction, that a grant of power to Congress does not, of itself, imply a prohibition of its exercise by the States. The powers granted to the general government are never to be considered as exclusive, unless they are made so in express terms, or unless, from the nature of the power itself, its concurrent exercise must necessarily produce direct repugnancy or incompatibility. But he argued, that this was by no means the inevitable result from a concorrent exercise of the taxing power, because its peculiar nature rendered it often capable of being exercised by different authorities at the same time, and even upon the same subject, without actual collision or interference.